Electric vehicle manufacturer Tesla has been dealt a significant blow regarding a 2019 fatal traffic accident involving its Autopilot system. A U.S. judge has officially upheld a massive $243 million compensation verdict, rejecting the company’s attempt to overturn the jury’s decision in the fatal Tesla Autopilot crash.
Court Rejects Tesla’s Appeal in Fatal Autopilot Crash Case
In a ruling issued on Friday, District Judge Beth Bloom determined that the company was partially responsible for the tragic incident. Judge Bloom stated there was sufficient evidence to support the jury’s verdict from August 2025. Furthermore, she emphasized that the company failed to present any new or valid arguments to challenge the decision, which requires millions to be paid to the victims.
This long-standing legal battle stems from a horrific event in 2019. The driver of a Model S, George McGee, had the Autopilot feature engaged when he bent down to pick up a dropped cell phone. At that moment, the vehicle violently collided with an SUV parked on the side of the road. The impact resulted in the death of Naibel Benavides Leon, who was standing next to the vehicle, and left Dillon Angulo with severe injuries.
Company Blames Driver, Prepares for Appeal
Tesla’s management has not yet made an official statement regarding Judge Bloom’s decision. However, legal experts believe it is almost certain that the brand will appeal the ruling to a higher court. Previously, company lawyers argued that the system had no defects and attempted to place the entire blame on the driver’s inattention.
While this major lawsuit continues, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) is also pursuing its own investigations into the safety and performance of Tesla’s Autopilot systems. This verdict adds another layer of scrutiny to the ongoing debate about the reliability of semi-autonomous driving features.
So, what are your thoughts on the safety of Tesla’s Autopilot system and this record-breaking fine? Share your opinions with us in the comments!
